Backup software for qnap, buffalo, drobo, and synology nas. Dear lifehacker, im thinking about building a nas networkattached storage for storage and backups, but i dont know if i should build a computer or use an old one i have kicking around, or if. So today we will discuss the main nas providers and their advantages and disadvantages. Personally, synology is a multi purpose nas for me. Liekwise the drobo dashboard software has seen a number of. I expect this drobo is not long for this world and i wanted to go with a standalone nas device instead of a shared drive on a server. Ive been using both the drobo 5c for local storage and synology ds916 for nas backup and the drobo has been nothing but a nightmare. Drobo announces easiest and fastest ever 5bay nas storage with 5n2. Synology nas have far more features to ensure a high level of connectivity, are less expensive and can be used.
Bear that in mind when choosing, as it is extremely handy to be able to fill your nas with differentsized drives as you expand. Backing up files to and from network attached storage nas devices is best done using a reliable backup software tool on a task schedule, so that it runs automatically at set intervals. Qnaps other nas deviceswe like synologys dsm software a little. The drobo b810i system has a removable magnetic cover that channels air to reduce hard drive and system fan noise. Were a virtual company made up of tech experts from across the globe. Drobo, buffalo, synology, netgear, qnap, iomega, iosafe, diskstation, readynas, lets collectively call them lnas, in an attempt to help our customers make the right choice when buying a nas device for backup purposes.
Ive used every nas i can get my hands on and i will say synology is one of the better ones. Ease of use qnap enters this with a nas that can be configured to do just about everything. The actual hdd size will be affected by the system partition and can vary between vendors, so the values calculated may differ from the actual results. The majority of our work is also done from a home office, where. Welcome to the sixth of seven nas stress tests, where we brutalize nas devices. Drobo synology as an iscsi target ars technica openforum. By the end of this blog post you should have a much better understanding about the difference between a synology nas and qnap nas, which is better for business between a drobo and a netgear and should you pick a thecus over an asustor. So i compared the nas out there and found out that the best choices. Aug 18, 2017 i have neither used drobo, nor synology. You can find the documents and files regarding the operating system, packages, desktop utilities and so on for your synology product to enjoy the latest and versatile features.
When you search for a nasdrive online, the market is dominated by qnap and. After leaving this page, you can reach your last comparison under comparisons. Page 1 of 2 drobo vs synology posted in general discussion. The drobo dashboard system software is designed with actual. The 5n is one of drobos most popular networkattached storage products. As always, we recommend following best practices, which include backing up your data prior to installing the latest firmware. View more drobo solutions learn more about your drobo view more win a drobo enter your email address to join the world.
Visit here for more information on choosing the correct hdd for your synology nas synology raid calculator offers you an estimate on the space utilization with various mixed hdd configurations and raid types. There is no support sla from qnap or synology support, so you could be. They can replicate between the devices through the native software and i use some desktop apps for backup to the nas. Drobo downloads for legacy products to ensure optimal performance and to take advantage of the latest features, set your drobo device to automatically check for software updates. Google drive replacement to sync files between my devices. Drobo, buffalo, synology, netgear, qnap, iomega, iosafe, diskstation. Hi, i am new to the entire nas idea, but since were working on several computers and we pay a lot of money every month to dropbox to keep our data synced somebody suggested me to get a nas.
Drobo requires you to install a program on your computer. Qnap and synology make the best stuff imho for the hobbyist who wants a solid functional nas without building up a custom solution. Its probably not superrelevant, but just in case it matters to you, it appears that current the synology nas software doesnt support smb3. Storage has to be the most annoying part of photography to nearly all photographers. I too thought the specs for the drobo fs made it a good choice over other nas raids, but it has been a massive hassle, 2 doa units and the software is buggy, check out the user forum on the drobo web site to see all the problems before making a buying decision. Apr 05, 2017 although drobo s new 5n2 includes several features that would appeal to entrylevel users, it doesnt stand up to modern performance standards. Give this backup software a try and youll find it is perfect for qnap, buffalo, drobo, and synology nas devices. We have 2 drobos in our main office, they will regularly break every 9 months or so. How does nextcloud weigh up against qnapsynologydrobo. A guide to helping you pick the right nas manufacturer for your needs network attached storage nas servers are fast becoming an essential piece of kit on the home. Drobo, synology, and lacie all offer this excellent functionality. Synologys management dashboard gives you vastly more capabilities, as well. Mar 30, 2017 liekwise the drobo dashboard software has seen a number of improvements sine i last played with it on the drobo 5n and has a number of new apps including surveillance applications and plex.
My whole family has access so we can share family photos and videos. In both cases, however, the main attraction is the software that comes with the nas. Aug 27, 2017 the drobo b810i system has a removable magnetic cover that channels air to reduce hard drive and system fan noise. Of course, you can still access a nas device the traditional way as a network drive and through an ip address from a windows, mac or linux. Network attached storage nas 5bay array, 2x gigabit ethernet ports the drobo 5n2 is the next era of simplified storage for your connected home or small office. I use it as a backup storage for my real web servers. Both synology and qnap are going to allow you to run tons of addon apps, like an itunes server, a download station, your own private cloud server, antivirus software, surveillance camera software, timemachine backups and a lot more. View more drobo solutions learn more about your drobo view more win a drobo enter your email address to join the world of drobo win a drobo enter your email address to. You know you need a reliable backup solution for all your photos, movies and music the stuff you bought and the memories you have created that are priceless but. The software, apps and flexibility are particularly appealing for the synology. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read.
Speed is always one of the biggest things we want to test when it comes to storage. Recommend a nas for small business data storage spiceworks. Synology is much better with qc of their software and are generally always ahead of. Synology nas versus drobo nas brand vs brand comparison. I found that the qnap solution is really a server that can run all types of virtual services. Liekwise the drobo dashboard software has seen a number of improvements sine i last played with it on the drobo 5n and has a number of new apps including surveillance applications and. I cheated and had to get my storage engineer to set this up for me in file management software.
Google trends is most positive for synology vs the others. In my testing, the synology edged out the drobo by. Oct 23, 2016 the 5n is one of drobos most popular networkattached storage products. After testing five new twobay networkattached storage nas. Basically, im trying to figure out which nas solution has the best privacy policy between the threee big shots. Lmk if you have any other questions about synology, the software is good. To find out more, please refer to why does my synology nas have a single volume size limitation of 16, 108, or 200 tb. While synology offers a wider variety of models an almost dizzying number, with barely understandable product naming, drobo offers more than just nas devices. I began researching a replacement for the 4bay drobo about six months ago. When synology asked me to look at their offering, i decided to. We didnt have any noise issues working in the same room with the system.
Why you shouldnt buy a nas like drobo, synology, buffalo. A network attached storage nas solution can be a godsend for those of you looking for ways to optimize and protect your data storage whether its for your home or for your office but deciding on the ideal network attached storage is no easy task, especially if you are not tech savvy or an it professional. When i originally looked into a nas device, i picked the qnap. The synology raid calculator makes recommendations based on the total capacity picked.
With all the things the qnap products can do, their configuration suffers. Welcome to the sixth of seven nas stress tests, where we brutalize nas devices to failure and then attempt to see if they can be. The latest generation drobo 5 bay nas, the 5n2 delivers an unparalleled user experience for data sharing, secure backup, remote access and disaster recovery solutions. It constantly has file corruption and unmounts itself despite all the lights being green. Ill update with how the synology works and whether the drobo with all my ripped dvds, and tons of important documents is resurrected or not. I replaced my freenas server with a drobo ronn bundgaard.
Which storage solution should i buy for personal home use. Why you shouldnt buy a nas like drobo, synology, buffalo, netgear, qnap if you are planning to use your nas device for hyperv or for backups, please read this article first before diving into further details. To ensure data is safe, the 5n2 also comes with the drobodr software solution developed by drobo. Synology september 16, 2011 john 3 comments ive been psyched for drobo ever since the first time i saw their video years ago where the guy played back a movie while pulling out and putting back in drives. Personally ive been using freenas and enjoying the hell out of it, but given the choice between drobo or synology i would choose synology all day. Look at the synology apps to figure out what you will. The failed disk was it a wd red for nas or wd blue. Drobo designed the 5n to bridge the gap between performance and affordability while keeping a small footprint that is ideal. Comparison of drobo 5n and synology diskstation ds916. My current nas is a qnap, and its been working flawlessly. Excellent windows storage server nas devices, with in built windows software filed ssd for fast deployment. Although drobos new 5n2 includes several features that would appeal to entrylevel users, it doesnt stand up to modern performance standards. Drobo products drobo solves the three major storage challenges in one device data protection, capacity adjustment, and ease of use. Drobo designed the 5n to bridge the gap between performance and affordability while keeping a.
As others say, synology is really on the same tier its a really tough call. I recently replaced the drobos with at freenas server. Try to use data recovery software to cobble together the data from the pieces. Buying your first nas for home or business can be a little bit intimidating. Drobo and synology face off in a battle of the nases. Lnas use similar embedded os code, so many nas boxes suffer from the same or. Ive fully read through qnaps and im currently waiting to speak with corporate about my questions almost done with synologys. Synology and qnap offer highend, userfriendly software that will make setting up the nas easy. Synology vs qnap vs drobo vs thecus vs netgear vs asustor. Some models can support larger single volume capacities after upgrading the installed memory capacity.
The comparison table below makes it easier to choose the most fitting nas. Ive been using drobo desktop nas devices for the better part of eight years. Their products shouldnt really be considered network attached storage, but instead should be considered network attached servers. With my full refund and so on i am going to buy from also i know good. Should you buy a synology nas or a drobo nas for your mac or windows. You can read about it in my article i replaced my freenas server with a drobo i build my freenas server in 2008 with an intel d945gclf2 atom 330 dualcore motherboard and cpu and six 1tb wd green drives. With drobodr, users can set up a pair of 5n2s to make an. Now, speaking of apps, youll know you are not a drobo person if you really want your nas to act like a little network server. As always, we recommend following best practices, which include backing up. In most of our performance benchmarks, the 5n2 was completely outclassed by our selected comparable nas. In my testing, the synology edged out the drobo by 1020% in various speed tests.